Minn Kota Edge vs. Motorguide X3

[bmb5482]

A. Minn Kota Edge Bow Mount Trolling Motor 12 Volt 45lbs Thrust 45" Shaft - MSRP $429.99
B. MotorGuide X3 Trolling Motor 12V 45lbs 45" - MSRP $379.99

Is there any reason why the Minn Kota is worth an extra $60?

[scbassfanatic]

I'm wondering the same as I am in the market for a 24 volt 70lb thrust. maybe not a fair comparison as the X3 is brand new model and the Edge has been around for a while. MG may have tried to hit the sell price lower than the edge line with intent to steal some of the business.

[Creel Limit Zero]

Depends on where you look, sometimes the difference is only $30-$40.  I don't know much about either of these models.  For me, I'm a Minnkota guy, because I like the way their foot pedal has the buttons on it.  I had a Motorguide once, for one outing and switched it out, I just didn't like the placement of the button on the foot pedal. 

One thing I would suggest, is I would consider upping to a 24 Volt Trolling motor.  It is a bit more pricey, and you'll need another battery, but it is well worth it.  If you are on the TM a lot, you will find yourself running your battery down on a 12 Volt... 

[hunter34]

over the years I have had several of both brands
I find that the minn kota were the most trouble free